Hi guys,

Start of a new week. Last couple of verses of chapter 5.

Here is the text:
--------
1 Timothy 5:20, “Those who sin are to be rebuked publicly, so that the others may take warning.”

Interesting points:
1. Paul builds on the preceding verse concerning the proper handling of accusations made against elders where he instructed not to entertain accusations against them unless two or three witnesses provided testimony. This was to protect properly vetted elders from frivolous or predatory accusations intended to distract them from their purpose or detract from their mission. Here, Paul instructs that elders who persistently sin should be publicly rebuked within the body of believers as a warning to the other elders and as a reassuring example to the congregation.

2. As Paul recognized that it is possible for an elder to sin and/or stray from the path of righteousness -- which not hurts themselves, but also other believers and the reputation of the church -- his instruction reflects an important aspect of accountability and discipline within the church: no one is above correction. The process for dealing with the elder is the same as other believers, as outlined in Matthew 18:15-17.

3. Given the level of responsibility, access to sensitive information and confidence with which an elder is entrusted, a public rebuke serves three functions: serves as a reminder to other elders that they are accountable to both God and the body of Christ, reassures the body of Christ that everyone (including elders/leaders) is held accountable for their actions AND warns the body of Christ of an elder’s propensity to sin in a particular area (if they decide to maintain the elder in position following genuine repentance) so they can remain vigilant and help in providing accountability for that elder.

Application.
Brothers, the responsibility of and confidence in an elder for righteous living cannot be understated. Entrusted to care for the flock, the church must not ignore abusive, predatory or wicked behavior in those called to be the chief servers of the church. That being said, elders can also stray from the path of righteousness or succumb to their own sinful nature.
As the purpose for a public rebuke is correction, a call to righteousness and for accountability, the heart of an elder whose sin is exposed publicly will be revealed. If the elder chooses the path of humility and repentance, he demonstrates the way back to righteousness and sets the example for reconciliation with the prodigal brother. If he decides to turn his back on the church rather than face humiliation, his prideful heart and stiff neck will sentence him to be treated like “a pagan or a tax collector”.
As members of the body of Christ, we must not fear accountability nor correction or ignore when those in positions of servant-leadership sin against God and man. Just as the requirement to entertain an accusation against an elder is higher to prevent petty attacks, disciplining an elder publicly ensures to those hurt (victims and the Church) that sins are not overlooked and that righteousness is the standard by which we should all (strive to) live by.